NCDRC Affirms Members’ Right to Sue Their Co-Op Society for Deficiency in Service

Facts of the Case

The case revolves around a dispute between a member of a co-operative housing society and the society itself. The complainant, Anil Advani, alleged that the co-operative society failed to provide essential services and engaged in unfair practices, leading to grievances requiring legal intervention. The core issue was whether members of a co-operative society could be classified as ‘consumers’ under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Legal Issues

1. Whether a co-operative society’s services to its members fall within the ambit of ‘service’ under the Consumer Protection Act?
   
2. Can a member of a co-operative society institute a consumer complaint against the society for deficiency in service?
   

Arguments by the Parties

• Complainant’s Arguments:
  
  • The complainant contended that the society had failed in its duty to provide essential services such as maintenance, repair work, and financial transparency.
    
  • Cited precedents where co-operative societies were held accountable for their service-related obligations.
    
  • Argued that he was a ‘consumer’ as per the definition under the Consumer Protection Act since he availed services from the society in exchange for maintenance charges.

• Respondent’s Arguments:
  
  • The co-operative society maintained that disputes among members and the society should be resolved under the co-operative societies’ internal dispute resolution mechanism.
    
  • It asserted that members of a society do not fall under the category of ‘consumers’ as the society operates on a principle of mutual benefit rather than a service-provider-consumer relationship.
    
  • It also relied on past judgments that restricted the scope of the Consumer Protection Act in the context of co-operative societies.
    

Court’s Reasoning and Judgment

The NCDRC ruled in favor of the complainant, holding that:

• Applicability of the Consumer Protection Act: The commission observed that members availing maintenance and other society-related services are indeed ‘consumers’ under the Act, provided that these services are not rendered gratuitously.
  
• Deficiency in Service: The court found that the society had failed to fulfill its obligations, causing inconvenience to the complainant. Such lapses in service are actionable under consumer law.
  
• Precedents Relied Upon: The court referred to significant past judgments, including:
  
  • K.K. Modi vs. K.N. Modi & Ors. (1998) – Discussing the scope of consumer disputes.
    
  • Zoroastrian Co-Op Housing Society Ltd. vs. District Registrar (2005) – Analyzing co-operative societies’ governance vis-à-vis consumer rights.
    
  • Secretary, Thirumurugan Co-op Agricultural Credit Society vs. M. Lalitha (2004) – Holding that co-operative societies providing financial services fall under consumer law.
    

Significance of the Judgment

This ruling sets a precedent for co-operative society members to seek redress under consumer law for any service-related deficiencies. It expands the scope of consumer rights, ensuring that members are not left without remedy against mismanagement and non-performance of societies.

Conclusion

The NCDRC’s decision reaffirms the principle that consumer protection laws apply to housing co-operative societies. It provides relief to members who suffer from deficient services, compelling societies to uphold their commitments. This landmark ruling will likely influence future litigation concerning the accountability of co-operative societies.

FAQs:

1. Can I file a consumer complaint against my housing co-operative society?

Yes, if your housing co-operative society is collecting maintenance fees or other charges in exchange for services (like repairs, security, or water supply), you are considered a consumer under the Consumer Protection Act. You can file a complaint if the society fails to deliver those services properly.

2. Are members of a co-operative society considered consumers under Indian consumer law?

Yes, as long as the services provided by the society are not free and are given in exchange for charges or fees, members can be treated as consumers. The law recognizes your right to complain if the society is deficient in service or acts unfairly.

3. What is a ‘deficiency in service’ by a co-operative housing society?

A deficiency in service means the society is failing to do something it is supposed to—like not maintaining lifts, failing to repair common areas, or not being transparent with finances. If you’re paying for these services and not receiving them, you can take legal action under consumer law.

4. Should co-operative society disputes always go through the Registrar or can they go to a consumer forum?

While many internal issues go through the co-operative society registrar, if the issue is about paid services and there’s a clear failure to deliver them, you can go directly to a consumer court. This is especially true if the society’s inaction has caused inconvenience or financial loss.

5. What legal remedies do I have if my housing society refuses to maintain the building or provide services I paid for?

You can file a case in the Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. You can seek compensation, refund, or direction to the society to perform their duties. The law protects residents from societies that neglect their responsibilities despite charging for services.

Stay informed with insights that matter. Follow us for more updates on key legal developments.

Disclaimer

The content provided here is for general information only; it does not constitute legal advice. Reading them does not create a lawyer-client relationship, and Mahendra Bhavsar & Co. disclaims all liability for actions taken or omitted based on this content. Always obtain advice from qualified counsel for your specific circumstances. © Mahendra Bhavsar & Co.